I think it depends on you and your knowledge.
I have a BS and MS in Electrical Engineering but I'm working as security engineer, and I think my degree were not so useful...
By the way, looking at your catalog, i think CIS would be better.. but many pentesters starts as developer... Honestly I don't like BS in CS and MS in Computer Forensics. It's possible to have a BS in CS and a MS in CIS ?
Otherwise, I agree with who said that this field doesn't really care about your degree..
I do also think CIS is much better, but I just want to be sure. I don't really have so much interest in developing, but that doesn't mean I hate it either. The thing is, I just want a BS degree, going for a MS is pretty inconvenient in my situation and also very costly. But, if it's the only way, I guess I don't have a choice do I?
That can be true although, if I get a degree in it, I do learn it in college don't I? Because if I didn't get the degree most likely I'll just take courses that I find useful. I really don't know, I've asked about this many times but seems like not too many pentesters are around or interested to reply.